Al's Coffee House - C&C please

[theantiquetiger]

I am still not sure if I even like the shot at all. I didn't capture what I saw before I took it.

I am leaning towards to sepia version (but I like BW photography)

http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8203/8179977882_e9b8b37cab_b.jpg

http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8477/8179942841_125b0aca8a_b.jpg

[Realist]

I think number 2 captures the mood a lot better than number 1.

[Bambi]

I quite like the second one- it captures the feel of an old fashioned feel. I like it very much.

[Marko]

I actually like the more realistic processing in shot 1.

I find the composition good but for me,...The scene needs people to liven it up.

[Runmonty]

As it is, I prefer the second one as well.

If it did have people in it as Marko suggested, then I think the maybe my choice could change

[asnow]

Definitely like the first one better. Not fussy with the colour in the second one. Agree with Marko's suggestion of having people in it.

[Lucky-Luc]

I much prefered the color version.

[QuietOne]

I think the detail stands out a lot better in the sepia toned one, but at least on my monitor, I really don't like the shade of the sepia.

[Paul72]

I like them both and I agree with Markos comment that it could do with people in the shots.