Perrier and roses

[JAS_Photo]

http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3579/3451414863_13ae942225_b.jpg (http://www.flickr.com/photos/jas_photos/3451414863/)

[JAS_Photo]

Yes, no, maybe?

[Greg_Nuspel]

In a way I like it because it makes me ask 'why', you're left wondering what is the story that puts the rose in a glass of Perrrier.

[AcadieLibre]

Just the crop looks off, where are the Perrier bubbles?

[MoinMoin]

First - I like the rose and all the sharp details to see. Also the background fits well. But... (what else ;-))... maybe you should have taken a bigger bowl. In this way the blossom lost the best of it's form.

[casil403]

I guess for me IMO the bright blue background distracts from the subject and I'm not really crazy about the crop...the rose is nice and I like the idea however. What about a different glass?
Not that I'm any kind of expert Raiven but you asked so I thought I would throw in my $0.02

[Gem]

I think it's the crop and (maybe) the angle that bothers me.

[kat]

I guess for me IMO the bright blue background distracts from the subject and I'm not really crazy about the crop...the rose is nice and I like the idea however. What about a different glass?
Not that I'm any kind of expert Raiven but you asked so I thought I would throw in my $0.02


I agree with this. For me though..the big thing it the background color..it doesn't seem to fit.