light and dark the sequel

[Bambi]

I posted a picture in the 'show your photos' but probably should have put it here since I wondered about the crop (after I posted).
Here's the original:
http://farm5.static.flickr.com/4022/4269652154_3d316f1caf.jpg

crop 1 shows a bit of the bank but cuts out the swamp:
http://lh4.ggpht.com/_eTzuNZZ7ZF0/S03xMoKc-fI/AAAAAAAADuE/9ZfiH7ZLILU/s800/tree%20a.jpg

and here's an even smaller crop:
http://lh6.ggpht.com/_eTzuNZZ7ZF0/S03xOYRLmqI/AAAAAAAADuI/W8MJdGjUzFs/s800/tree%20b.jpg


let me know what you think. I also have many chances to reshoot this tree so can go back if you have suggestions :thumbup:
Also feel free to take your own swing at the crop if you like

:thankyou:

[JAS_Photo]

Both crops work for me. :) although I think I favour the second.

[tirediron]

I like both crops as well; I would consider though, going back to the pixel room and perhaps doing some leves/curves adjustments and/or burning and dodging to produce a more even sky. As is, I find the darker sky top left to be a bit of a distraction.

[Mad Aussie]

I like both crops as well!

I guess it depends on whether you want the lake included or not.

I think the 2nd crop without the lake it actually a bit more impacting.

[Marko]

Lovely image!:highfive:

I like the original crop the best!

IMO all it needs is a bit of dodging at the bottom.

[Bambi]

thanks for the input guys. TI-how would I go about lightening up that sky with all those branches in the way? :confused: I am new to the whole burn/dodge thing.

[scorpio_e]

Both crops are good. I was torn between the two. I like the original crop the best. Nice work