Are you sick of mills yet?

[Gem]

Both are nice, but like others said, I like the second better! The water flow looks great.

[Redneck]

Definitely #2 here for me also. Shows the water movement well and some historical definition.
#1 , I just can't get past that guardrail, and hydro wires jumping out at me.

[Greg_Nuspel]

I'm for two as well. I find it defines it as mill and the flowing water is great.

[Wicked Dark]

Thanks much. I think early morning is the only time to get the mill from the side and include the whole building and sky...otherwise it's just too bright.