Wide angle zoom, which one??

[AcadieLibre]

For Canon I have the 16-35 2.8 L lens and so in love with it. I also have a Sigma 10-20mm F4-5.6 for when I want something a bit wider but since I bought the Canon lens I do not think I have used the Sigma but I rarely need something that wide and it just a personal preference for me.

EDIT: The Sigma I really liked until I bought the Canon and would recommend it for the optics quality and price.

[edG]

Do you find it to be a bother not being able to attach any filters, though? Your shots are great, and they really convince me that this lens is a nice and sharp one. I am still quite undecided, but it seems it is going to be between the Sigma and the Tokina. I like the f2.8 on the Tokina ....; and thanks for your input

Not much of a filter guy, you could hold up a large lee or other resin filter by hand in front if you have a tripod.

[Matt K.]

Actually ended up buy a Tokina 12-24 f4. Price was right on eBay ($320.00) for a used one, thought I could not go wrong with that, and really, I did not. Went out today with buddy Greg, he has the 11-16 f2.8. So really, all the difference for 1mm and the 2.8? Hmmm, we both shot @ f8 today, so why would i need this. And the range is a bit larger on the 12-24, the 11-16 might as well be a fixed focus lens. So far I am really happy with my choice. ..... next on the list: fisheye

[JAS_Photo]

The little Rokinon/Samyang fish eye is a great lens. Sharp as heck and very fun. I think I got mine from Cameta Camera:

Search Results

Here is a shot of the Peace Bridge taken with that lens, directly into the sun.

http://www.flickr.com/photos/jas_pho...in/photostream

[Matt K.]

The little Rokinon/Samyang fish eye is a great lens. Sharp as heck and very fun. I think I got mine from Cameta Camera:

Search Results

Here is a shot of the Peace Bridge taken with that lens, directly into the sun.

Peace Bridge | Flickr - Photo Sharing!

Looks like a nice lens, is it the 8mm? I was looking at the Nikon 10.5mm ....

[JAS_Photo]

Yes it is 8mm.

[TheGreatMike]

I have the Tokina 11-16 f2.8! Takes awesome pics but might as well be a prime ,very little zoom .if the 8-16 has good iq I would go with it ,but i do love the tokina 11-16.