Very tough call. I really like the softness of the B&W, and that you can still see the detail of the decking in the shadow of the railing. I get kind of an antique vibe from it. On the other hand, the color shot really makes me want to sit in a comfy chair and relax by the beach. Consider that I live in Minnesota and it's almost December. I guess I'm trying to say it seems like a mood thing more than anything, depends on what you're going for. It would be interesting to see a sepia treatment on both photos, hint, hint Both are very nice, though.