Neighbourhood Photos

[Iguanasan]

Cool. I like the crop. With my original I was really keen to get the sun reflecting off the water but this one is nice as well.

[Marko]

For shot 2, to my eye that area is too long and wide for so much clipping, it steals the whole show, so i could see Rm's instinct to suggest the vertical crop.
I like Rm's take on the cropping but i prefer the tones in your original image.

I really like shot 3 here. If it were mine I'd likely burn in the bright tree at left by 5-10%.
I'd likely dodge the white water at center all the way to the background by the same amount.
I might play with bringing out a bit more detail in the shadows in the foreground water, and selectively increasing some of the the deepest blacks.
I might even try a version where I cropped out the sky.
My goal would be to get the eye to travel with the water.
Although the setting is gorgeous, what brought you to that particular spot is most likely the water. So that's the story I would try to highlight if this were my image.
Hope that makes sense and it's just my 2 cents

[Iguanasan]

For shot 2, to my eye that area is too long and wide for so much clipping, it steals the whole show, so i could see Rm's instinct to suggest the vertical crop.
I like Rm's take on the cropping but i prefer the tones in your original image.

I really like shot 3 here. If it were mine I'd likely burn in the bright tree at left by 5-10%.
I'd likely dodge the white water at center all the way to the background by the same amount.
I might play with bringing out a bit more detail in the shadows in the foreground water, and selectively increasing some of the the deepest blacks.
I might even try a version where I cropped out the sky.
My goal would be to get the eye to travel with the water.
Although the setting is gorgeous, what brought you to that particular spot is most likely the water. So that's the story I would try to highlight if this were my image.
Hope that makes sense and it's just my 2 cents

Thanks for the comments, Marko. I think I actually understand all your points Cheers!

[Jason]

I really like the third one, Iggy. I can almost hear the water reverberating off the rocks.

[Randitola]

I love the way the light is captured in feathery spores in the first one.

[Iguanasan]

Thank you, Jason and Randitola.

[JAS_Photo]

A rather nice neighbourhood you got!

[BradT]

The stream shot is amazing you can feel the water. How close to the water were you?

[Hillbillygirl]

Nicely captured on all Iggy. Really likin that second one, and also agree with Marko, as he has nailed it for me.