Help choosing a macro lens

[Barefoot]

I have the older version of the Nikkor 60mm without the internal focusing motor. That's never been a problem for me when doing macro work and it can be had for half the price of the later model. Still, I wish I had opted for the 105mm 2.8. It seems as though the 60mm is often in its own way.

After more than a few years of shooting with Tamron glass, I can also say that money invested in Tamron lenses is money well spent.

[Rdbender]

I love my Tamron 90mm 2.8 on my nikon D5100 and D7100

[Marko]

Still, I wish I had opted for the 105mm 2.8. It seems as though the 60mm is often in its own way.

I agree and did this research years ago - I have the the 105mm 2.8 and it is fab for Macro!